Ann Arbor City Council Voting Chart for the Meeting of June 3, 2024
Here’s the agenda.
There was a long, 34-item Consent Agenda at this meeting. Mayor Taylor recused himself from CA-30, an agreement with the Sam Bernstein Law Firm to pursue insulin pricing litigation, due to a conflict of interest. CA-9 was an agreement for an exclusive negotiating period for 4M to develop the long-blighted site at 415 W. Washington. CMs Eyer and Radina voted no, preferring a more traditional RFC process for the site. CA-13 was the renewal for the Spin scooter/e-bike contract. It was amended to shorten the term to 3mo instead of 1y with the city having an option to extend each quarter up to the original term.
PH-1/B-1 and PH-3/DS-1 were the zoning and site plan for the Five Corners PUD near the intersection of State and Packard. It was amended to add justifications for the land use, most likely due to the objections of the property owners next door, which currently houses a Domino’s Pizza. A lawyer for that landlord was the only speaker opposed to this housing development, while two others spoke in favor.
PH-2/B-2 were changes to the snow removal ordinance, increasing fines for failure to remove snow from sidewalks adjacent to commercial and multifamily properties.
DC-1 was an appointment to add Erica Liu to the Independent Community Police Oversight Commission.
DC-2 was a resolution in support of increasing State funding for public transit.
DC-3 was a resolution that hopes to ensure that facial recognition technology is used responsibly and equitably by the Ann Arbor Police Department.
DC-4 was a Resolution Authorizing Application and Implementation of Michigan Shared Streets and Spaces Grant.
Agenda Item | Mayor Taylor | Disch (Ward 1) | Harrison (Ward 1) | Song (Ward 2) | Watson (Ward 2) | Radina (Ward 3) | Ghazi-Edwin (Ward 3) | Eyer (Ward 4) | Akmon (Ward 4) | Briggs (Ward 5) | Cornell (Ward 5) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CA-1 Resolution to Approve the 2024 Ann Arbor Jaycees 71st Annual Summer Carnival at Pioneer High School - June 17 to June 24, 2024 | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-2 Resolution to Accept a Fair Food Network Grant for the Ann Arbor Farmers Market for $60,000.00 and Appropriate Funds (8 Votes Required) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-3 Resolution to Ratify and Appropriate FY 24 Budget and Allocations for High Impact Grants as Part of the New Human Service Partnership - $350,183.00 Budgeted (General Fund) (8 Votes Required) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-4 Resolution to Recommend Awarding a One-Year Contract to The Davey Tree Expert Company for Routine Park Tree Pruning & Park Forestry Services ($450,000.00, RFP #23-47) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-5 Resolution to Appropriate Funds for the Carlisle Wortman Contract for Building Plan Review and Inspection Services ($100,000.00) (8 Votes Required) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-6 Resolution to Appropriate Funding for GovOS Short Term Rental Software ($49,900.00) (8 Votes Required) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-7 Resolution to Order Election, Determine Ballot Question for Charter Amendment for Approval of the Park Maintenance and Capital Improvements Millage for 2025 through 2044, and Reaffirm the Park Maintenance and Capital Improvements Administrative Millage Policy (7 Votes Required) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-8 Resolution to Approve 416 Long Shore Drive Development Agreement (CPC Recommendation: Approval - 7 Yes, 0 No) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-10 Resolution to Approve the Installation of Traffic Calming Devices on Bird Road (Newport Road to Huron River Drive) ($87,500.00) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-11 Resolution to Approve the Installation of Traffic Calming Devices on Henry Street (Golden Avenue to Packard Street) ($70,000.00) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-12 Resolution to Prohibit On-Street Parking on the East Side of Page Avenue from Esch Avenue to Harpst Street | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-14 Resolution to Approve Amendment No. 1 to the Professional Services Agreement with Orchard, Hiltz & McCliment, Inc. for Professional Engineering Services ($88,500.00 Amendment, $388,500.00 Total Contract) (RFP #22-05) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-15 Resolution to Approve Amendment No. 2 to the Professional Services Agreement with Geosyntec Consultants of Michigan, Inc. for Hydroelectric Dams - FERC Title 18 Part 12, Subpart D (Part 12D) Inspections and Other Engineering Services ($125,000.00 Amendment, $340,700.00 Total Contract) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-16 Resolution to Approve Amendment No. 3 to the Professional Services Agreement with NTH Consultants, Ltd. for Barton Dam Right Embankment Remediation ($227,700.00 Amendment, $1,170,587.77 Total Contract) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-17 Resolution to Approve a Sole Source Purchase Order to Idexx for Bacteriological Testing Media and Associated Supplies ($36,000.00) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-18 Resolution to Approve Bulk Chemical Purchases for the Water and Water Resource Recovery Plants of Sodium Hypochlorite (JCI Jones Chemical -Approximately $271,500.00/year), Hydrofluorosilicic Acid (Univar Solutions - Approximately $35,360.00/year), Pebble Quicklime (Graymont - Approximately $945,000.00/year), and Ferric Chloride (PVS Technologies - Approximately $142,496.00/year) Approximately $1,394,356.00/year. | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-19 Resolution to Approve Professional Services Agreements with Fishbeck, Thompson, Carr & Huber, Inc. for $500,000.00, Stantec Consulting Michigan Inc. for $500,000.00, and Jacobs Consultants Inc. for $500,000.00 for Water Treatment Professional Engineering Services (RFP #24-02) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-20 Resolution to Approve Amendment No. 4 to the Professional Services Agreement with Hubbell, Roth & Clark, Inc. for the Headworks Improvement Project at the Water Resource Recovery Facility, RFP No. 19-12 ($230,000.00 Amendment; $1,899,875.53 Total Contract) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-21 Resolution to Approve Purchasing Agreements for Utility Infrastructure Materials from Core and Main LP (Not-to-Exceed $789,392.68) and Ferguson Waterworks (Not-to-Exceed $76,306.00) for One Year (ITB-4743) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-22 Resolution to Approve a 5-Year Best Source Professional Services Agreement with American Conservation & Billing Solutions, Inc. for a Customer Portal and Consumption Data Analytics Solution (Aquahawk) ($222,641.67) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-23 Resolution to Approve a Purchase Order with Cogsdale Corporation for Annual Software Maintenance and Support for FY 2025 ($156,110.78) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-24 Resolution to Approve a Two-Year Service Agreement with Emergent Health Partners for Ann Arbor Fire Department Dispatch and Related Services and Appropriate Funding ($348,674.25/2yrs) (8 Votes Required) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-25 Resolution Authorizing Water and Sanitary Sewer Capital Recovery Charges for 3039 Stone School Rd. | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-26 Resolution to Approve Temporary Outdoor Sales, Service and Consumption of Alcoholic Beverages during the 2024 Ann Arbor Art Fair | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-27 Resolution to Approve the Reauthorization of the Main Street Area Business Improvement Zone | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-28 Resolution to Approve Grants of Easement for Access over 819 W. Huron Street to Abutting Property Owners (8 Votes Required) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-29 Resolution to Approve a Legal Services Agreement with Cummings, McClorey, Davis & Acho, P.L.C. Relative to the Estate of Seth Sugar by its Personal Representative Bryan Sugar v. City of Ann Arbor et al Litigation | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-31 Resolution to Approve Amendment 1 to the Professional Services Agreement with Elevate Energy for Administration of the Residential Rebate Program and to Authorize the Disbursement of Funds ($4,250,000.00 in FY24-26) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-32 Resolution To Approve a Cost Sharing Agreement with the Downtown Development Authority for the Geothermal Advisory and Professional Services Agreement with Stantec Consulting Services, Inc. ($100,000.00) (8 Votes Required) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-33 Resolution to Approve a Professional Services Agreement with DiClemente Siegel Design Inc. for Election Center Renovation Design Services ($107,067.00) RFP #24-11 | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-34 Resolution to Approve an Agreement of Sale for a Portion of the So-called “Transformer Alley” to Bluestone Realty Advisors, LLC in an Amount Not Lower than $240,000.00 to be Deposited into the General Fund (8 Votes Required) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-9 Resolution to Approve Entering into a Six-Month Negotiating Period for the Possible Sale of the 415 W. Washington Site | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ❌ | ✅️ | ❌ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-13 - Motion to Approve as Amended by Akmon Resolution to Approve a Right-of-Way License Agreement with Pheenix USH LLC for the Operation of Dockless Electric Micromobility Devices in the City of Ann Arbor | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-13 - Motion to Amend by Akmon Reduce term of contract to 3mo with quarterly renewals through original 1y term | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-30 Recusal Recuse Mayor Taylor from voting on CA-30 due to conflict of interest | Recused | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
CA-30 Resolution to Approve a Retainer Agreement with Weitz & Luxenberg, P.C. and The Sam Bernstein Law Firm for Legal Services to Support the City’s Participation in the Insulin Pricing Multi-District Litigation, In re: Insulin Pricing Litigation, MDL No. 3080 | Recused | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
B-1 - Motion to Adopt as Amended on Second Reading by Disch An Ordinance to Amend the Zoning Map, Being a Part of Section 5.10.2 of Chapter 55 of Title V of the Code of the City of Ann Arbor, of 1.3 Acres from C1AR (Campus Business Residential) to PUD (Planned Unit Development), 732 Packard PUD Zoning and Supplemental Regulations (CPC Recommendation: Approval - 8 Yeas and 0 Nays) (ORD-24-11) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
B-1 - Motion to Amend by Disch An Ordinance to Amend the Zoning Map, Being a Part of Section 5.10.2 of Chapter 55 of Title V of the Code of the City of Ann Arbor, of 1.3 Acres from C1AR (Campus Business Residential) to PUD (Planned Unit Development), 732 Packard PUD Zoning and Supplemental Regulations (CPC Recommendation: Approval - 8 Yeas and 0 Nays) (ORD-24-11) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
B-2 - Motion to Adopt on Second Reading by Cornell An Ordinance to Amend Sections 4:60 and 4:61 of Chapter 49 (Sidewalks) of Title IV (Streets and Sidewalks) of the Code of the City of Ann Arbor (ORD-24-12) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
DS-1 Resolution to Approve 732 Packard “5 Corners” PUD Site Plan and Development Agreement (CPC Recommendation: Approval - 8 Yeas and 0 Nays) | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
DC-1 Resolution to Appoint Erica Liu to the Independent Community Police Oversight Commission | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
DC-2 - Motion to Approve as Amended by Edwin Resolution in Support of Boosting State Investment in Public Transit | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
DC-2 Also CC local officials and the Governor | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
DC-3 Resolution Directing the Appropriate Use of Facial Recognition Technology | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |
DC-4 Resolution Authorizing Application and Implementation of Michigan Shared Streets and Spaces Grant | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | ✅️ | Absent | ✅️ |